Skip to content
Safe Deposit Guide

Safe deposit boxes in Bay Shore, NY (2026)

Non-bank vaults
0
Branches with boxes
9
Updated
Oct 20, 2026

9 of 14 bank and credit union branches here count: their own page lists boxes, or their bank's published policy is to rent boxes at most branches. The others are listed below: call to ask.

Private vaults and depositories

How we verify

Bank or credit union renting boxes

We're still verifying vaults in Bay Shore.

We haven't confirmed a private vault here yet. Bank and credit union branches are listed below; leave your email at the bottom and we'll tell you when a vault near Bay Shore is verified.

Private vaults near Bay Shore

Within 50 miles. Private vaults first, then depositories, closest first.

Private vault Open 24/7 Anonymous rental Biometric access

UltraVault New York

580 5th Ave, Lobby 1, New York, NY · 38.2 mi

From
On request
Access
24/7
Insurance
Included

Checked

Call

Banks and credit unions

Grouped by institution. Branches whose own page lists safe deposit boxes come first, then those of banks whose published policy is to keep renting boxes. Call ahead: availability changes branch by branch.

Credit union Still rents boxes

Fourleaf Federal Credit Union

2 branches · policy checked Oct 11, 2026 (source)

Policy note

25% senior discount; sales tax added where applicable.

  • Bay Shore

    591 E Main St, 11706 · Mon - Thurs: 9am - 5pm Friday: 9am - 6pm Saturday: 9am - 2pm

  • Bay Shore Supermarket

    834 Sunrise Hwy, 11706 · M-Fri: 10:00am - 6:00pm Saturday: 10:00am - 4:00pm Sunday: 11:00am - 4:00pm

Bank Still rents boxes

Bank of America

1 branch · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)

Policy note

To inquire about opening a new box, visit your nearest financial center or schedule an appointment; availability and fees are given by the local financial center.

  • Bay Shore Branch

    838 Sunrise Hwy, 11706

Bank Still rents boxes

Citibank

1 branch · policy checked Oct 8, 2026 (source)

Policy note

A Citibank checking or savings account and automatic annual debit of the rent are required; fee waivers or discounts apply to some relationship tiers.

  • Bay Shore Branch

    77 E Main St, 11706

Bank Still rents boxes

Dime Commercial Bank

1 branch · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)

Policy note

Aspire 50 checking includes a no-cost 3”X 5” box for one year, with 50% off larger boxes (based on availability), per a 2023 disclosure.

  • Bay Shore Branch

    380 Montauk Hwy, 11706

Bank Still rents boxes

Flagstar Bank

1 branch · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)

  • Bay Shore East Main Street Branch

    130 E Main St, 11706

Credit union Still rents boxes

Jovia Financial Federal Credit Union

1 branch · policy checked Oct 11, 2026 (source)

  • Bay Shore

    2 E Main St, 11706 · Monday: 9:00am - 5:00pm Tuesday: 9:00am - 5:00pm Wednesday: 9:00am - 5:00pm Thursday:…

Bank Still rents boxes

TD Bank

1 branch · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)

  • Bay Shore Branch

    479 Montauk Hwy, 11706

Credit union Still rents boxes

Teachers Federal Credit Union

1 branch · policy checked Oct 9, 2026 (source)

  • Bay Shore

    1360 Sunrise Hwy, 11706 · Mon-Thur: 9:00am-5:00pm; Fri: 9:00am-6:00pm; Sat: 9:00am-2:00pmb

3 other institutions in Bay Shore (not confirmed to rent boxes here)
Bank No new boxes

Capital One

1 branch · policy checked Oct 12, 2026 (source)

  • South Shore Mall Branch

    1701 Sunrise Hwy, 11706

Bank No new boxes

Santander Bank

1 branch · policy checked Oct 12, 2026 (source)

  • Bay Shore Branch

    300 E Main St, 11706

Bank Closing existing boxes

Chase

3 branches · policy checked Oct 8, 2026 (source)

Policy note

Existing renters are to be notified in advance; no nationwide closing timeline was given.

  • Bay Shore Branch

    537 E Main St, 11706

  • Brentwood Bay Shore Branch

    1650 5th Ave, 11706

  • West Bay Shore Branch

    840 Sunrise Hwy, 11706

Nearby cities

Get an email when a vault opens near Bay Shore

Safe deposit boxes in Bay Shore: questions

How many private vaults are there in Bay Shore?

We have not verified a private vault in Bay Shore, NY yet. We add listings only after checking them on the operator's own site or by phone.

Do banks in Bay Shore still rent safe deposit boxes?

We list 9 bank and credit union branches in Bay Shore, NY that rent safe deposit boxes: the branch's own page lists them, or its institution publishes a policy of renting them. Availability varies by branch, so call first. See our bank status page for each bank's current policy.

Is the content of a safe deposit box insured?

Not by the bank or the FDIC (FDIC). Many private vaults include insurance; each listing says whether it does and for how much.