Skip to content
Safe Deposit Guide

Banks with safe deposit boxes in Bay Shore, NY

These branches list safe deposit boxes on their own page, or belong to banks whose published policy is to keep renting them. Availability changes branch by branch, so call before you go.

Listings
5

Looking for every option? All safe deposit boxes in Bay Shore

Bank Still rents boxes

Bank of America

1 branch · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)

Policy note

To inquire about opening a new box, visit your nearest financial center or schedule an appointment; availability and fees are given by the local financial center.

  • Bay Shore Branch

    838 Sunrise Hwy, 11706

Bank Still rents boxes

Citibank

1 branch · policy checked Oct 8, 2026 (source)

Policy note

A Citibank checking or savings account and automatic annual debit of the rent are required; fee waivers or discounts apply to some relationship tiers.

  • Bay Shore Branch

    77 E Main St, 11706

Bank Still rents boxes

Dime Commercial Bank

1 branch · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)

Policy note

Aspire 50 checking includes a no-cost 3”X 5” box for one year, with 50% off larger boxes (based on availability), per a 2023 disclosure.

  • Bay Shore Branch

    380 Montauk Hwy, 11706

Bank Still rents boxes

Flagstar Bank

1 branch · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)

  • Bay Shore East Main Street Branch

    130 E Main St, 11706

Bank Still rents boxes

TD Bank

1 branch · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)

  • Bay Shore Branch

    479 Montauk Hwy, 11706

Questions people ask

Which banks rent safe deposit boxes in Bay Shore?

Bank of America, Citibank, Dime Commercial Bank, Flagstar Bank, TD Bank publish a policy of renting boxes, with 5 branches in Bay Shore, NY. Box availability varies by branch: call before you go.

Is the content insured?

The contents of a bank safe deposit box are not insured by the FDIC (FDIC). Many private vaults include insurance or sell it; each listing says so when the operator publishes it. You can also ask your home or renters insurer whether your policy can cover them.