-
Wallkill Branch
624 Route 211 E, 10941
Checked Source
Listed among this branch's services: Safe Deposit Boxes
Offers boxes -
Middletown Branch
240 Dolson Ave, 10940
Safe deposit boxes in Middletown, NY (2026)
- Non-bank vaults
- 0
- Branches with boxes
- 8
- Updated
- Oct 20, 2026
8 of 18 bank and credit union branches here count: their own page lists boxes, or their bank's published policy is to rent boxes at most branches. The others are listed below: call to ask.
Private vaults and depositories
Branch page lists safe deposit boxes Branch of a bank that rents boxes: call to confirm
We're still verifying vaults in Middletown.
Banks and credit unions
Grouped by institution. Branches whose own page lists safe deposit boxes come first, then those of banks whose published policy is to keep renting boxes. Call ahead: availability changes branch by branch.
ConnectOne Bank
1 branch · 1 branch lists boxes on its own page · policy checked Oct 9, 2026 (source)
-
Middletown Branch
485 Schutt Road Ext, 10940
Checked Source
Listed among this branch's services: Safe Deposit Boxes
Offers boxes
Heritage Financial Federal Credit Union
2 branches · policy checked Oct 9, 2026 (source)
-
Heritage Financial CU
161 Dolson Ave # 5, 10940 · M-Th 8:30am-5pm Fri 8:30am-6pm Sat 9am-2pm 24 Hour ATM Summer Sat Hours: 9 AM to 1 PM…
-
Heritage Financial CU
25 Rykowski Ln, 10941 · M-Th 8:30am-5pm Fri 8:30am-6pm Sat 9am-2pm 24 Hour ATM Summer Sat Hours: 9 AM to 1 PM
-
Dunning Road Branch
715 Route 211 E, 10941
-
Orange Bank & Trust Company
212 Dolson Ave, 10940
Bank of America
1 branch · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)
Policy note
To inquire about opening a new box, visit your nearest financial center or schedule an appointment; availability and fees are given by the local financial center.
-
Middletown Branch
364 Route 211 E, 10940
-
Route 211 Branch
468 Route 211, 10940
7 other institutions in Middletown (not confirmed to rent boxes here)
KeyBank
2 branches · none listed on the bank's branch page · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)
Policy note
Must be 18+; $5 one-time set-up fee (waived for Key Select/Privilege/Private Client customers and employees); rent paid annually in advance; contents limited to $25,000 under agreement; no gold bullion or non-collectible currency; contents not FDIC insured.
-
Middletown Branch
101 Dolson Ave, 10940
-
Middletown Branch
545 Route 211 E, 10941
-
First Federal Savings of Middletown
22 James St, 10940
-
Middletown
40 Lloyds Ln, 10940 · Monday – Wednesday: 9:00 am – 5:30 pm Thursday ?Friday: 9:00 am – 6:00 pm Saturday: 9:00…
-
Crystal Run
140 Crystal Run Rd, 10941 · M-Th 9-5F 8-6; Sat 9-2
Citizens Bank
1 branch · policy checked Oct 12, 2026 (source)
Policy note
Existing renters only; service kept in about 440 branches (Jan. 2025); some branches are phasing boxes out.
-
Middletown East Branch
253 Route 211 E, 10940
-
Wallkill East Branch
1 Industrial Dr Ste 100, 10941
-
Middletown Fairgrounds Plaza Branch
12 Lloyds Ln, 10940
-
Orange Plaza Branch
440 New York Highway 211 East, 10940
Nearby cities
- Circleville, NY 0 private · 1 bank & CU 5 mi
- Goshen, NY 0 private · 4 bank & CU 6 mi
- Otisville, NY 0 private · 1 bank & CU 6 mi
- Florida, NY 0 private · 1 bank & CU 9 mi
- Wurtsboro, NY 0 private · 1 bank & CU 10 mi
- Chester, NY 0 private · 3 bank & CU 10 mi
- Montgomery, NY 0 private · 6 bank & CU 11 mi
- Maybrook, NY 0 private · 1 bank & CU 11 mi
- Pine Bush, NY 0 private · 2 bank & CU 13 mi
- Warwick, NY 0 private · 3 bank & CU 14 mi
- Washingtonville, NY 0 private · 2 bank & CU 14 mi
- Walden, NY 0 private · 2 bank & CU 15 mi
Get an email when a vault opens near Middletown
Safe deposit boxes in Middletown: questions
How many private vaults are there in Middletown?
We have not verified a private vault in Middletown, NY yet. We add listings only after checking them on the operator's own site or by phone.
Do banks in Middletown still rent safe deposit boxes?
We list 8 bank and credit union branches in Middletown, NY that rent safe deposit boxes: the branch's own page lists them, or its institution publishes a policy of renting them. Availability varies by branch, so call first. See our bank status page for each bank's current policy.
Is the content of a safe deposit box insured?
Not by the bank or the FDIC (FDIC). Many private vaults include insurance; each listing says whether it does and for how much.