Short answer: a bank or credit union box is the cheapest option if a branch near you still has one free. A private vault costs more, but it is often the only option where banks stopped renting boxes, and many add longer hours and insurance on the contents.
Side by side
| Bank or credit union box | Private vault | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Median $25 (3 x 5) to $90 (10 x 10) a year | Median starting price $33 a month |
| Hours | Branch opening hours | 15 of 37 private vaults offer 24/7 access, and 25 are open on weekends (24/7 vaults included) |
| Insurance | Contents not insured by the FDIC | 13 of 37 private vaults include insurance (8 of them state $5,000 per box) |
| Account needed | Often a discount for customers; credit unions require membership | No bank account; ID rules vary by vault |
| Availability | Select branches, sizes can run out; some banks stopped | Private vaults in 14 states, mostly in large metro areas (26 states counting depositories, dealers and self-storage sites that rent boxes) |
Bank prices come from 6,148 prices published by 1,189 banks and credit unions; private vault figures are for the 37 locations our directory lists as private vaults. The 24 dealers, self-storage sites and other places that rent boxes, and the 22 precious metals depositories, are counted separately. Our private vaults page lists the 61 places that rent boxes (the 37 and the 24), so our category pages show higher totals than the ones above (21 places open 24/7 and 37 open on weekends), and the 83 on our home page add the 22 depositories. Bank figures were checked between October 9 and November 5, 2026, and the private vaults and other places between October 9 and November 5, 2026. The price medians are explained in the cost guide.
When a bank box makes sense
- A branch near you has the size you need (check banks that still rent boxes).
- You open the box a few times a year, during business hours.
- You will insure valuable contents yourself, through your home or renters policy.
When a private vault makes sense
- Your bank stopped renting boxes or has a waitlist. Chase is phasing boxes out, and Citizens, Santander and Capital One no longer rent new ones (details).
- You need access outside banking hours. Some vaults are open evenings and weekends, and a few around the clock (24-hour vaults).
- You want the contents insured without arranging a separate policy (insured boxes).
- You need a bigger box than branches offer, or a small vault room (large boxes).
What to check before you rent a private vault
- How long it has been open, and who owns it. Several "vault" websites announce openings that never happened. We only list a vault as open after checking it, and we mark announced vaults clearly.
- The insurance policy: amount per box, insurer, exclusions, and how you prove a loss.
- Access rules: biometrics, appointments, who else can open your box, what happens if you lose the key or stop paying.
- The written agreement, including what happens to your property if the company closes.
- Price per year, setup fee and deposit, to compare with a bank box.
Find one near you
Start from your city: each city page lists the private vaults and the bank and credit union branches that still rent boxes, with prices and the date we checked. Browse by state or see all private vaults.