Skip to content
Safe Deposit Guide

Banks with safe deposit boxes in Geneseo, NY

These branches list safe deposit boxes on their own page, or belong to banks whose published policy is to keep renting them. Availability changes branch by branch, so call before you go.

Listings
4

Looking for every option? All safe deposit boxes in Geneseo

Bank Still rents boxes

KeyBank

1 branch · 1 branch lists boxes on its own page · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)

Policy note

Must be 18+; $5 one-time set-up fee (waived for Key Select/Privilege/Private Client customers and employees); rent paid annually in advance; contents limited to $25,000 under agreement; no gold bullion or non-collectible currency; contents not FDIC insured.

  • Geneseo Branch

    66 Main St, 14454

    Checked Source

    Listed among this branch's services: Safe Deposit Box

    Offers boxes
Bank Still rents boxes

Community Bank

1 branch · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)

  • Geneseo Branch

    4218 Lakeville Rd, 14454

Bank Still rents boxes

Five Star Bank

1 branch · policy checked Oct 9, 2026 (source)

Policy note

Discount for consumers with an active Premier or Plus Checking account.

  • Geneseo Branch

    4431 Genesee Valley Plz, 14454

Bank Still rents boxes

Tompkins Bank & Trust

1 branch · policy checked Oct 9, 2026 (source)

  • Geneseo Branch

    11 South St, 14454

Questions people ask

Which banks rent safe deposit boxes in Geneseo?

KeyBank, Community Bank, Five Star Bank, Tompkins Bank & Trust publish a policy of renting boxes, with 4 branches in Geneseo, NY. Box availability varies by branch: call before you go.

Is the content insured?

The contents of a bank safe deposit box are not insured by the FDIC (FDIC). Many private vaults include insurance or sell it; each listing says so when the operator publishes it. You can also ask your home or renters insurer whether your policy can cover them.