Skip to content
Safe Deposit Guide

Banks with safe deposit boxes in Fishers, IN

These branches list safe deposit boxes on their own page, or belong to banks whose published policy is to keep renting them. Availability changes branch by branch, so call before you go.

Listings
18

Looking for every option? All safe deposit boxes in Fishers

Bank Still rents boxes

KeyBank

1 branch · 1 branch lists boxes on its own page · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)

Policy note

Must be 18+; $5 one-time set-up fee (waived for Key Select/Privilege/Private Client customers and employees); rent paid annually in advance; contents limited to $25,000 under agreement; no gold bullion or non-collectible currency; contents not FDIC insured.

  • Fishers Branch

    7450 E 116th St, 46038

    Checked Source

    Listed among this branch's services: Safe Deposit Box

    Offers boxes
Bank Still rents boxes

Old National Bank

1 branch · 1 branch lists boxes on its own page · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)

  • Fishers Branch

    9765 E 116th St, 46037

    Checked Source

    Listed among this branch's services: Safe Deposit Boxes based on availability

    Offers boxes
Bank Still rents boxes

Fifth Third Bank

3 branches · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)

Policy note

Refundable $25.00 key deposit required when opening a safe deposit box. Fifth Third Preferred Checking includes a complimentary 3x5 box (discounts on larger sizes); Private Bank clients get one complimentary box, any size, based on availability. No general eligibility/account requirement or standard

  • 116th And Allisonville Bc Branch

    11555 Allisonville Rd, 46038

  • Fishers Corner Banking Center

    11662 Commercial Dr, 46038

  • Hamilton Southeastern Banking Center Branch

    13681 E 116th St, 46037

Bank Still rents boxes

Huntington Bank

3 branches · policy checked Oct 8, 2026 (source)

  • Fishers East 96th St. Branch

    7878 E 96th St, 46037

  • Fishers Marsh Branch

    11001 Allisonville Rd, 46038

  • Geist Banking Office Branch

    11640 Olio Rd, 46037

Bank Still rents boxes

PNC Bank

3 branches · policy checked Oct 8, 2026 (source)

Policy note

$5 discount on the annual rent when it is debited automatically from a PNC account.

  • Brooks School Road Branch

    11680 Brooks School Rd, 46037

  • Fishers Branch

    7270 E 116th St, 46038

  • North By Northeast Branch

    7876 E 96th St, 46037

Bank Still rents boxes

BMO

2 branches · policy checked Oct 8, 2026 (source)

Policy note

Check each branch page for box availability by size.

  • 116th & Brooks School Branch

    12620 E 116th St, 46037

  • Fishers Branch

    7150 E 116th St, 46038

Bank Still rents boxes

Regions Bank

2 branches · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)

  • Fishers Branch

    7447 E 116th St, 46038

  • I69 And 96th St Branch

    8758 E 96th St, 46037

Bank Still rents boxes

Bank of America

1 branch · policy checked Oct 20, 2026 (source)

Policy note

To inquire about opening a new box, visit your nearest financial center or schedule an appointment; availability and fees are given by the local financial center.

  • Fishers Branch

    9770 E 116th St, 46037

Bank Still rents boxes

First Merchants Bank

1 branch · policy checked Oct 9, 2026 (source)

Policy note

Some checking and private banking accounts include a 25% or 50% discount on box rental where available.

  • Fishers Geist Branch

    11521 Olio Rd, 46037

Questions people ask

Which banks rent safe deposit boxes in Fishers?

KeyBank, Old National Bank, Fifth Third Bank, Huntington Bank, PNC Bank, BMO and 4 more publish a policy of renting boxes, with 18 branches in Fishers, IN. Box availability varies by branch: call before you go.

Is the content insured?

The contents of a bank safe deposit box are not insured by the FDIC (FDIC). Many private vaults include insurance or sell it; each listing says so when the operator publishes it. You can also ask your home or renters insurer whether your policy can cover them.